Did Sigmund Freud say Irish are impervious to psychoanalysis?
Abdon M. Pallasch ponders the truth of a provocative line from the movie The Departed. “What Freud said about the Irish is: We’re the only people who are impervious to psychoanalysis,” declares Colin Sullivan (Matt Damon) in Martin Scorsese’s film The Departed.
Were the only people who are impervious to psychoanalysis?
Freud created the language we use to think and talk about our minds. The fact that we think about our inner lives at all is largely attributable to Freud. Second, I am Irish, and Freud is commonly quoted as saying that the Irish are the only people impervious to psychoanalysis.
What is the Irish temperament?
What are the Irish really like? I think the answer I like best comes from the eminent historian, Carl Wittke. “The so-called Irish temperament is a mixture of flaming ego, hot temper, stubbornness, great personal charm and warmth, and a wit that shines through adversity.
Is Freud theory scientific?
That Freudian theory is not science is suggested by the important difference between giving a systematic account of it, and doing the same for any of the physical sciences. To explain Freudian theory properly, one has to recount its origins and growth.
What did psychoanalysis become?
Psychoanalysis was developed in the late nineteenth century both as a theory and a form of therapy. Based on the premise that unconscious conflicts form the root of psychological issues, psychoanalysis suggests symptoms can be reduced by bringing these conflicts into conscious awareness.
What were Freud’s theories?
Key Theories He also proposed that personality was made up of three key elements, the id, the ego, and the superego. Some other important Freudian theories include his concepts of life and death instincts, the theory of psychosexual development, and the mechanisms of defense.
What did Sigmund Freud say about the Irish?
He believed the Irish have no interest in picking apart their own brains. Freud is also claimed to have stated that the Irish are a mass of contradictions and impervious to the rational thought processes that might resolve them. And finally, another follower of Freud supposedly said the Austrian doctor categorized people as “Irish and non-Irish.”
Are the Irish the only race impervious to psychoanalysis?
Photograph: Casparius/Hulton Archive/Getty Images It was with a certain sadness recently that I finally called off the search for the origins of the quotation wherein Sigmund Freud is claimed to have said that the Irish were the only race impervious to psychoanalysis.
How did Sigmund Freud influence psychology?
Psychoanalysis became a dominating school of thought during the early years of psychology and remains quite influential today. In addition to his influence on psychology, Freud’s ideas have permeated popular culture and concepts such as Freudian slips, the unconscious, wish fulfillment, and the ego are even commonly used in everyday language.
Did Sigmund Freud say “this is one race for no use whatsoever”?
The Irish psyche and Sigmund Freud. In the movie The Departed, Matt Damon’s character claims that Freud said: “This is one race of people for whom psychoanalysis is of no use whatsoever.”. – Sigmund Freud (about the Irish) Some claim this Freudian quotation was derived from a phrase by one of his followers.
